Home ReadBooksThe False Mirror (The Damned #2): The War Leaves Earth and Gets a Lot Bigger

The False Mirror (The Damned #2): The War Leaves Earth and Gets a Lot Bigger

by Hutch Morzaria
Cover of The False Mirror, book two of The Damned by Alan Dean Foster, showing a man in a lab coat flanked by aliens
Rating: 8.0/10

The False Mirror is a really good follow up to A Call to Arms, and the first thing it does is get off Earth. Book one was mostly about one planet finding out what it was, with the aliens wincing at us from orbit and Dulac arguing with everybody. Book two jumps a few centuries on and the whole galaxy is the battleground now, humans are the Weave’s front line, and the war that had been grinding along for thousands of years is finally starting to tip. It’s a much grander canvas and I liked it a lot, because the first book’s biggest limit was that everything happened on or around one planet, and as fun as the aliens-judging-us angle was, I wanted to see what humans actually did once they were let loose on the war. This is that book. And then, just when it looks like humanity has made the difference, the Amplitur answer us with something I didn’t see coming at all.

The Amplitur build their own humans

Their answer is the Ashregan, an elite warrior people raised from birth inside the Amplitur’s Purpose and bred to stand toe to toe with human soldiers. For the first time in the series the bad guys have something that can match us, and you can feel the confidence the Weave had built up starting to wobble. Then a Weave patrol picks up an Ashregan soldier called Ranji, and when their scientists start studying him they find out he isn’t an alien at all. He’s human. The Ashregan are humans the Amplitur captured and changed, rebuilt to look like something else and to be open to the mental pushing the rest of us shrug off. That’s the false mirror of the title, a people engineered to look like the enemy they were bred to kill, and it’s a cracking idea for a middle book because it takes the one thing that made us special in book one and turns it back on us.

It reminded me a bit of the Clans in Lethal Heritage, warriors bred and raised for nothing but the fight, except here the twist is personal. Ranji isn’t fighting a stranger. He’s fighting his own species and he’s never known it, and the Weave suddenly have to decide what you even do with a prisoner like that. Do you treat him as an enemy soldier, as a victim, as a weapon you can point back the other way? The book spends real time on that, and it’s the part I found myself thinking about afterwards, more than any of the battles. It also makes the Amplitur a lot nastier than they were in book one. Before, they were these slightly smug, slightly creepy unifiers who’d rather talk you into the Purpose than shoot you. Now they’ve taken a whole human population, raised its children as something else and pointed them at their own kind, and the polite talk about helping everyone find their place in the Purpose sounds very different after that.

Ranji is the reason this one works

What makes The False Mirror better than a lot of middle books is that it stays close to one person. The Weave work out how to undo what the Amplitur did and strip out the mental blocks they put in his head, and then Ranji has to work out how human he actually is, which is a lot harder than flipping a switch. He’s spent his whole life believing he’s Ashregan, being proud of it, and now everyone’s telling him the thing he was proud of was a lie someone else wrote for him. That’s a great hook for a character and I bought every step of him getting his head round it. When he goes back and starts persuading other Ashregan to turn, with the Weave promising to help free the rest of his people, it feels earned rather than convenient. There’s a lovely awkwardness to watching him try to be human for the first time, taking in a species he was raised to see as the enemy and realising he’s got their temper, their stubbornness and their knack for violence, all the stuff book one made such a fuss about, and he doesn’t know whether to be proud of it or not.

I’ll be honest, the rest of the cast doesn’t get anywhere near the same attention. Most of the Weave scientists and soldiers around Ranji are there to react to him, and the other characters are pretty flat next to him, which is fair. I didn’t mind much, because Ranji carries it, but if you need a whole ensemble to care about you won’t get that here. And the battles are a bit of a background hum. This is still a series that cares more about what the war means than about who’s winning which skirmish, which suits me fine, though it won’t suit everyone. If you came out of book one wanting the action turned up, this isn’t really that book either, it’s the ideas that get turned up.

A third side nobody knows about

My favourite thing in The False Mirror, and the reason I rate it as highly as I do, is what happens once the Ashregan have been cured. Undoing the Amplitur’s tinkering has a side effect nobody planned for. Ranji and the restored humans come out the other end able to do the exact thing the Amplitur do, push other species’ minds, and that’s a power the Weave would be horrified by if they ever found out. So they don’t tell them. They keep it to themselves and form a secret group, the Core, unknown to the Weave, to the Amplitur, even to ordinary humanity, and suddenly the war isn’t a two-sided thing anymore.

That’s such a good move for the series. These “new” humans are a separate third group that neither side knows exists, sitting in the middle of a galaxy-wide war with a power both sides would treat as the worst thing imaginable, and it opens up a really interesting future for the last book. The whole first book was about whether the peaceful species could live with a violent ally. Now the violent ally has a hidden branch that can reach into their heads, and you just know that’s going to matter. It also makes the Weave look a bit different. They spent book one worrying that humans were too violent to trust, and they were right to worry, just not about the thing they were watching. I loved the feeling of the story getting bigger and more dangerous right at the point where I thought it was heading for a straightforward win, and it made the gap between this and the last book feel very long.

It leaves a lot hanging, and that’s mostly fine

I’ll admit the ending won’t be for everyone. The False Mirror doesn’t really wrap anything up, it gets the Core in place, gets Ranji where he needs to be, and stops, and there are a few loose threads I’d have liked tied off. A lot of middle books in trilogies do this, you get to the last page and realise you’ve been reading the first half of a much longer story, and I usually grumble about it. Here I mostly didn’t, because the thing it’s setting up is so much more interesting than anything a tidy ending could have given me. The war that looked almost won now has a secret running through the middle of it, and the people who saved the galaxy are hiding something from the people they saved.

What sticks with me most is how the title keeps working on you. The Ashregan were a false mirror of humanity, sure, but by the end the cured humans are a false mirror too, people the Weave think they understand who’ve quietly become something else. It’s a smart little idea and it doesn’t hammer you with it. There’s also something sad about Ranji’s story that I didn’t expect from a book I mostly remember as fun, a man who gets his real identity back and immediately has to start keeping secrets again, just different ones this time, from different people. That bit of sadness gives the book more weight than I expected, and it’s the thing I’d point to if anyone told me middle books never matter.

4 out of 5. Bring on the last one.

You may also like

Leave a Comment