Here is where it gets all Inception’esque (I know that’s not a word but you get what I mean I’m sure, so let’s just go with it) as the dreams are what this episode is all about. Not just one dream, but dreams within dreams, and by the end you’re never quite sure which level anyone is on. Clara wasn’t expecting to ever see the Doctor again, so bumping into him on Christmas Eve made the reunion even better, and the fact they’d parted on the back of two whopping great lies (Clara’s being that Danny Pink was still alive and the Doctor’s being that he’d found Gallifrey) gets dealt with in a way I really liked, without getting in the way of the main story.
Dreams within dreams
When the Doctor and Clara enter the base, they and the surviving crew members are almost immediately attacked by a host of the dream crabs that fall from the ceiling, however before they are consumed (captured?), Santa Claus appears on a reindeer outside the base itself and helps them to escape from what seems to be certain death (btw the scene with all the toys is literally priceless and almost by itself makes the episode). Santa (played by Nick Frost) is really good, and the role really shines because he doesn’t just roll over for the Doctor and his huge brain but banters back and forth with him. The two of them bickering like an old married couple is half the fun, and the elves chipping in with their own one-liners in the middle of it made me laugh out loud more than once.
Doctor: “Ah, go make a naughty list!”
Santa: “I have mate, and you’re on it!”
Nick Frost was brilliant, and having Santa in it made the whole thing feel that bit more special. Doctor Who is great at taking a familiar old figure and giving it a timey-wimey twist, or in this case a dream-weamy one, and putting Santa into the show was always going to be a risk, but they pulled it off and I can’t imagine the episode without him. Other fans seem to agree, one review I read called it an instant classic of a Christmas episode, and I’m not going to argue. The crew would’ve been dead without him too, so I’m guessing they were pretty pleased he turned up.
Saying goodbye to Danny
When the Doctor has Clara retrieve the remains of the first crab that they found, he quickly realizes that he has in fact sent her into a trap. Clara, awakening, finds herself somewhere else, somewhere where Danny has not in fact died, and they’re together celebrating Christmas. The Doctor tries to communicate with her (and while he’s successful) he’s unable to get Clara to leave Danny, and realizes that the only way he can get her back is to go into the dream himself. With Santa’s help, the Doctor enters Clara’s dream and makes her realize that she needs to wake up. Here you come to realize that even a dead Danny is still pretty awesome!
The biggest loose end left over from series 8 was Danny dying in Death in Heaven, and this is where it finally gets tied up. His death gets one more scene, a really heartwarming one (and, not to mention, heartbreaking) where Clara finally comes to terms with losing him. Awakening from the dream (by realizing that it is in fact a dream) the Doctor and Clara jump up to see the dream crabs crumbling to dust beside them. However before they can escape, the Doctor realizes that although they thought they’d escaped … they were actually still inside a dream, because while there might have been 8 people on the base (4 comatose in the medical bay with facehuggers on them, and the 4 the Doctor and Clara were talking to) there really were only 4 people there, as the ones on the beds were the same people. He proves this by having them read through the operations manual, and when they acknowledge the truth, the creatures on the beds start to attack.
Waking up, again and again
Managing to escape the base, they attempt to enter the TARDIS only to find the Doctor and Clara emerging with facehuggers too. Once again Santa comes to the rescue and helps the survivors escape on his sleigh. Realizing that if they’re to truly escape they need to will themselves awake, the others gradually wake from the nightmare, leaving Clara and Santa alone. The Doctor eventually arrives to help Clara escape, as he realized she wouldn’t want to leave the dream by herself, but by the time he comes it’s been decades and Clara is an old, old lady. The Doctor, in an extremely nice twist, doesn’t really see this himself and is so happy to have Clara back, but when he realizes again that he’s still dreaming he’s finally (one hopes) able to wake himself up and gets back to Clara again. This time he’s in time, and Clara is returned to us, and the two of them head off in the TARDIS together like the last few episodes never happened.
This was definitely one of the better Doctor Who episodes of recent years, and while it might have cribbed somewhat shamelessly from popular culture, it did it in a way that gave credit to what it borrowed, and for letting us say goodbye to Danny Pink the right way … Last Christmas is one of, maybe even the, best holiday specials Doctor Who has managed.
When old Clara showed up, did you think that was her actual ending, or did you know straight away it was just another dream? Tell me in the comments.
1 comment
The dream crabs put me in mind of the Weeping Angels and the Silence, the monsters this show does best are the ones that turn something ordinary against you, and here it’s falling asleep. Santa being the thing that keeps waking them up is a lovely twist on the whole idea.