I review the Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. pilot, the first episode of Marvel’s new TV show, which brings Phil Coulson back from the dead and puts a new team around him.
Starting the show with Coulson walking back in is the big reason I loved it, along with Skye, the Bus and a powered man the team chooses to save. I give it 10.0 out of 10.
You have to give the Agents of SHIELD pilot a 10, don’t you? It’s the start of the show, Marvel’s first proper TV series set in the same world as the films, and it opens by bringing Phil Coulson back from the grave. After watching him die on the Helicarrier in The Avengers, the man whose death was the push the whole team needed to come together, seeing him walk back into a room with that same dry little smile was all it took. I was in. Everything else in the episode is a bonus on top of that, and there’s a lot of bonus, a new team, a big plane, a mystery, and a final shot I didn’t see coming at all. It’s not a perfect hour of TV, but it’s exactly the start I wanted.
Coulson walks back in
The episode doesn’t make you wait long. Maria Hill (Cobie Smulders) is interviewing Grant Ward, a field agent who works alone and likes it that way, and as she’s telling him the team she’s putting him on is led by someone with a lot more clearance than he has, Coulson strolls in out of the shadows. Ward’s face says what we’re all thinking. Coulson’s explanation is that the Avengers were told he died to give them a reason to fight, which I’m happy to accept, and that he spent his recovery in Tahiti, which he describes as a magical place in a way that sounds a little too rehearsed. I’ll come back to that. For now, Clark Gregg is just a joy to watch, and his return feels earned rather than cheap, mostly because he plays it as if nothing much has happened. No big speech, no tearful reunion, just Coulson being Coulson, and somehow that makes it land harder.
There’s a moment after he leaves a meeting, with Hill and a doctor alone in the room, where one of them says he can never know. Know what? It’s the hook of the whole season right there, dropped into the first episode with no explanation, and I loved it. A man everyone thought was dead is back, he’s being lied to about how, and he doesn’t seem to notice anything’s off. That’s a much better reason to keep watching than any monster of the week, and I’m going to be watching Coulson very closely every time somebody mentions Tahiti. It also gives the show something darker to work with underneath all the jokes, the way Arrow’s first season kept a secret running under every week’s case, and I think it’s going to need it. The Coulson I remember from the films was the calm one in every room, the man who could stand next to Thor and Iron Man and not look small, and part of the fun here is seeing that same calm turned into a weakness. If he’s not asking the questions, somebody is making very sure he doesn’t.
A team that isn’t one yet
Coulson’s building a small team that flies around in a huge plane the crew calls the Bus. Ward is the specialist, good with a gun and terrible with people. Melinda May (Ming-Na Wen) is a pilot who’s stepped away from field work and only comes back because Coulson asks her to, and there’s clearly a story there nobody’s telling yet. Leo Fitz (Iain De Caestecker) and Jemma Simmons (Elizabeth Henstridge) are the science pair, an engineer and a biochemist who finish each other’s sentences and talk faster than anyone else on television, Matt Smith’s Doctor included. None of them really know each other yet, and the episode’s honest about that. It’s more a set of introductions than a team, but they’re good introductions. I’d have liked a little more of May, who barely says ten words and is somehow the most interesting person on the plane because of it, and Ward is still mostly a jaw and a gun at this stage. But you can see where the show wants to go with them. Ward has to learn to work with people, May has to decide whether she really wants to be back, and Fitz and Simmons have to survive their first trip out of the lab without fainting.

The real way in is Skye (Chloe Bennet), a hacker who lives out of her van and posts videos about a mysterious hooded hero. She’s part of the Rising Tide, a group of hackers who want to expose S.H.I.E.L.D.’s secrets, which makes her the one person in the show who’s on the outside looking in, the same place I am. She’s sarky, smart and doesn’t trust any of them, and it works. Her interrogation scene with Ward is a lot of fun, the two of them trying to out-stare each other across a table with a truth serum involved. The whole cast spends a lot of the hour trading quips around the Bus, and most of them land, though some of the dialogue is so pleased with itself it’s almost winking at the camera.
Mike Peterson and the choice to save him
The case of the week is Mike Peterson (J. August Richards), a laid-off factory worker and single dad who’s suddenly got superpowers he doesn’t understand. He saves a woman from a burning building, and Skye films it and puts it online. It turns out somebody’s been experimenting on him, and the procedure that made him strong is also making him unstable, to the point that he’s likely to explode. By the end he’s on a train station platform with a hostage and a bomb inside his own body, with his young son watching, and the team has to decide whether the safest option is to take him out for good. It’s a really strong way to define what this team is going to be about. Richards is great in it too, he plays Mike as a decent man who’s frightened and angry and humiliated all at once, someone who wanted to be a hero for his kid and got turned into a weapon instead. You can’t help rooting for him even when he’s at his most dangerous, which is exactly what the finale needs.
Because they don’t. Coulson talks to him, man to man, about being a father and being thrown away by people who should have looked after him, while Fitz and Simmons race to come up with a way to stop him. Ward ends up taking the shot, but with Simmons’s non-lethal “night-night gun” rather than a real bullet, and Mike drops instead of dies. I loved that. The movies are all about the big fight, and this show is telling me from the first episode that its version of heroism is a S.H.I.E.L.D. agent choosing to save the dangerous man instead of killing him. I didn’t expect a show about secret agents to have that much heart. It’s also a nice turn for Skye, who spent the whole episode assuming S.H.I.E.L.D. were the bad guys, the men in suits who make inconvenient people vanish, and ends it watching them go out of their way to keep a man alive. That’s what gets her to take Coulson’s offer seriously, and it’s what got me to take the show seriously too.
A flying car to finish
And then the last scene, Coulson asking Skye to join the team properly, her climbing into his beloved red vintage car Lola, and Lola lifting off the road and flying away. It made me laugh out loud, and it’s a perfect way to say this show knows exactly where it comes from. Lola’s the kind of thing that makes S.H.I.E.L.D. feel like it’s been around for decades, with a whole history of gadgets and adventures we’ve never seen, and I want to know every one of them. It’s a big, fun, slightly silly finish, and the right one for a show that’s just introduced a hacker, a dead man walking and a secret in the space of an hour. It also tells me the show won’t take itself too seriously, which after a week of every channel promising me gritty, dark new dramas is a relief. I’ll take a team of misfits in a flying car over another brooding detective any day.
The Agents of SHIELD pilot gets a 10.0 out of 10 from me, simply for bringing Coulson back and kicking off what already feels like it could be something special. If the rest of the season keeps throwing twists like that Tahiti line at me, I’m going to be here every week.
What do you think Coulson can never know, and is Tahiti really that magical? Tell me in the comments.
2 comments
Lola taking off at the end made me laugh out loud. The bit that stuck with me afterwards, though, is that Mike’s powers come out of the same Extremis tech that had soldiers blowing up in Iron Man 3, so the show’s tied itself straight into the films from week one and the whole world feels that bit bigger for it.
[…] falling ratings. I agreed with some of the criticism at the time, but having gone back and watched the early episodes again I also think expectations were just too high, everyone wanted the Avengers every week and […]