God Emperor of Dune, and Reading a Series in the Wrong Order

God Emperor of Dune was the first book in this series I ever read, which was a mistake, and I absolutely hated it. Nothing made sense. A creature that was mostly worm and used to be a man, ruling a galaxy from a cart, monologuing about breeding programmes at people who were not allowed to leave the room. It was far too weird for me and I put it down thinking the whole series was not for me.

Reading it in the wrong order nearly cost me the series

That is worth saying plainly, because I suspect I am not the only person who has bounced off Dune by starting somewhere daft. Going back to this one after Dune, Dune Messiah and Children of Dune turned it into a completely different book. Not my favourite of the six, but one I genuinely enjoyed, and the difference was entirely context.

Once you have watched Leto II as a nine-year-old, once you have seen the vision his father refused and the price he agreed to pay for taking it instead, the thing on the cart stops being a bizarre monster and becomes the consequence of a decision you watched somebody make. Understanding where he came from and why he exists was the shift that changed my whole mindset about this book. On its own it is a curiosity. In sequence it is the payoff.

It is worth saying that this is not a problem unique to Dune. Plenty of long series have a book that only makes sense from inside, and the difference here is how far this one goes. It is not a slower entry or a side story. It is a different genre, told by a different kind of narrator, about a character who was a child two books ago and is now a geological feature. Nothing prepares you for that if you have not read the approach.

I suspect the wrong-order problem is more common than anyone admits, because this is the Dune book most likely to be sitting on a charity shop shelf on its own. The first three get bought as a set and kept. This one gets picked up by people who liked the films, or who found it in a box, and it is the single worst possible introduction to anything Herbert wrote. If somebody tells you they tried Dune once and it was incomprehensible nonsense about a worm king, there is a decent chance this is the book they actually read.

Three and a half thousand years of deliberate boredom

Leto has held the throne since the end of the previous novel. The sandtrout have covered nearly all of him, he is effectively immortal, and there is no light left in which he passes for a man. He holds a total monopoly on spice, keeps an army of women called Fish Speakers, and has spent three millennia making the galaxy as dull as he can manage. Travel is rationed. Weapons are controlled. The Fremen have been reduced to Museum Fremen, performing rituals they no longer understand.

All of that is on purpose, and that is the part that makes the book work once you can see it. Leto’s Peace is stagnation held in place by force so that when it finally breaks, humanity bursts outward in every direction at once and can never again be gathered up and pointed by any single power, himself included. He has been breeding toward one specific outcome the whole time: a person invisible to prescience. Siona Atreides is that person, and he funds her rebellion and lets her steal his journals because she is the result he has waited thirty centuries for.

An immense worm-bodied figure carried on a ceremonial cart across a high bridge over a river gorge

It is also worth being honest about what the reading experience is actually like, because I do not want to oversell my own change of heart. Long passages of this book are a very old, very lonely creature explaining his reasoning to people who are not allowed to disagree, and there is no plot underneath a good deal of it. If that is not something you can sit with, no amount of context will rescue it, and I would not tell anyone they are wrong for stopping. What context does is change what the monologuing is for. Read cold, it is an author lecturing you. Read after three books, it is a character who has been alone for three thousand years and has nobody left to talk to, which is a different thing entirely and quite a lot sadder.

Reading it in sequence also reframes the boredom itself. A galaxy where nothing has happened for three thousand years is a miserable place to spend four hundred pages, and that is the intended effect rather than a failure of invention. You are meant to feel the flatness, because the argument of the book is that this is what safety actually costs and that no amount of it is worth the price. Cold, that is just a dull setting. In sequence it becomes a thesis you are being made to live in, which is a considerably more interesting thing to sit through.

Duncan, Moneo and Hwi

The latest Duncan Idaho ghola was my way into all this, a man from the era of the first book dropped into a galaxy that has moved past everything he recognises, asking blunt questions everyone else stopped asking centuries ago. That is exactly why Leto keeps ordering new ones, and the relationship between them is poisoned from the start because Leto has done this dozens of times and knows how it ends.

Moneo is the saddest figure in the novel. He has served faithfully for decades, went through the desert test himself, and knows what his master is and roughly what is coming for his daughter. And Hwi Noree is built by the Ixians specifically to be the one thing Leto cannot refuse, which is ordinary kindness aimed at a monster who has not been offered any in three thousand years. He works out what she is within moments of meeting her, says so, and it still works. She is how he arranges his own death, an event he has been planning for longer than most civilisations last.

Moneo deserves more attention than he usually gets, because he is the only person in the book living at a human tempo. Leto thinks in centuries and Duncan thinks in the reflexes of a man three thousand years dead, and Moneo is simply a tired administrator with a daughter he cannot protect and a boss he cannot refuse. Every scene he is in acquires a floor because of it. He is also the only person in the book who both understands the situation and has to keep living inside it, which makes his resignation far more damning than Duncan’s outrage.

The Fish Speakers, the Museum Fremen and the Ixians

Some of the strangest furniture in this book is also some of the most interesting once you stop fighting it. The Fish Speakers are an army made up entirely of women, devoted to Leto as a god rather than as a commander, and used far more for administration than for fighting. His stated reasoning, laid out at length in the journals, is that armies of men reliably turn into instruments of rape and pillage and his do not. The novel does not push back on him much, and that is one of the places where a modern reader is likely to want a word with the author rather than the character.

The Museum Fremen are the saddest joke in the series. The people who terraformed a planet and broke an empire have been reduced to performing water rituals for tourists, on a world that barely has a desert left, drawing a stipend for pretending to be their own ancestors. Leto keeps them that way deliberately. Set against the first novel, where the Fremen are the most vital thing on the page, it is a bleak piece of long-range plotting and it does more to sell three thousand years of stagnation than any amount of lecturing.

The Ixians are the other real pressure on him, and the only power in the galaxy still doing genuine technical work rather than maintenance. They built Hwi, they build the devices Leto tolerates despite the old prohibitions, and their ambassador Malky is one of very few characters allowed to be funny at the God Emperor’s expense and survive it. Nayla, the Fish Speaker who worships Leto absolutely and follows orders without ever interpreting them, is the instrument that makes the ending work, and Herbert is careful to show that her total faith is simultaneously what makes her useful and what makes her dangerous.

Hwi is also the one place the book allows itself something like tenderness, and it lands harder for being so rare. Leto has spent three thousand years unable to be touched, unable to eat, unable to do anything a person does, and what finally reaches him is somebody being kind to him on purpose. That the kindness was engineered by a rival power does not make it less effective, and Herbert is careful not to let Leto pretend otherwise. He knows exactly what is happening to him and lets it happen, which is the closest thing to a human decision he makes in the entire novel.

What it sets up

A very large share of this novel is Leto thinking, and long stretches pass with no plot at all. That is the thing people quit over and I quit over it myself the first time. What changed my mind is that the book is not an indulgence stuck in the middle of a series. It is the hinge. Everything in the last two books happens because of what Leto does here and because of what the Scattering throws outward when his peace finally breaks.

For my money it kicked off the two that follow and it delivered. Read in sequence, with the first three behind you, it earns the strangeness. Read cold, as I did, it is close to impenetrable.

The other thing I appreciate more now is how completely Herbert commits. There is no framing device softening it, no cutaway to a livelier subplot, no reassurance that the strangeness is temporary. He wrote a novel narrated substantially by a tyrant in the body of a worm and then declined to apologise for it across four hundred pages. Whether or not you finish it, that is not a writer coasting on a successful series, and the two books that follow could not exist without the ground this one clears.

So my position on it has completely reversed, and I want to be clear that the book did not change. I did. Everything I disliked on the first attempt is still in there, unaltered: the journals, the stillness, the total absence of anything resembling a conventional plot. What changed is that I now know who is talking and what it cost him to still be talking, and that turns four hundred pages of lecture into four hundred pages of a very old creature justifying himself to the only audience he has left, which by then is me.

Rating: 4/5.

Related posts

The Humanoids (Jack Williamson): The Robots That Protect Us Right Out of Everything

Challenger’s Hope (The Seafort Saga #2): Nick Gets His First Ship

The Wanderer: The Planet That Ate the Moon and the Cat Woman Who Pulled a Man Out of a Tsunami