This review covers “Dalek,” the sixth episode of the first revived series of Doctor Who, in which Christopher Eccleston’s Doctor comes face to face with a captive Dalek inside Henry van Statten’s private vault beneath the Utah desert. It looks at how the Doctor’s hatred for the chained, near-powerless creature curdles into something close to fear, and how Rose Tyler’s touch sets off the chain of events that leaves the Dalek questioning what it is.
The piece argues that this is the episode where the Ninth Doctor’s Time War trauma stops being a passing mention and becomes the point, with Henry van Statten’s mistreatment of his own staff underlining the same argument about power that the Dalek’s captivity makes. No numerical rating is given.
“World War Three” ended with me counting down to the next Saturday, and “Dalek” is the episode that actually earned that. Five weeks of Slitheen and shop dummies and a spinning London Eye, and then Russell T Davies drops the show’s most famous monster into an underground bunker in Utah and lets it sit there in chains for most of an hour before it does anything at all. That restraint is the whole trick. I went in expecting a monster runaround and got something closer to a hostage situation, and it’s the Doctor who’s taken hostage by his own history.
The setup is simple enough. Henry van Statten is an American billionaire who’s built a private museum of alien technology deep under the Utah desert, and the prize exhibit is a “metaltron,” something his people dragged out of a Russian icebox decades ago and have never managed to identify. He’s got wreckage from crash sites all over the world down there, cherry-picked and locked away long before any government agency gets a look in, and none of it interests him half as much as the one exhibit that’s still alive. The Doctor and Rose land in the bunker chasing a signal and walk straight into it. He knows what it is before the guards even get the cage open, and after the fart jokes and Downing Street explosions of the week before, watching him go pale in a lift is a hell of a gear change.
The Doctor I Hadn’t Seen Yet
I’ve watched this Doctor be angry before, but not like this. The moment he realises what’s chained up in that cell, something drops out of his face, and what replaces it is closer to fear than fury, even though what comes out of his mouth is all fury. He goads it. He needles it. At one point he’s leaning into the cage telling it to just die already, and Eccleston plays it like a man picking a fight he already knows he can’t walk away from clean. It’s the ugliest I’ve seen this incarnation of the Doctor, and it’s not an accident. He’s mentioned being the last of his kind a couple of times now, always in passing and never for long, and this is the first episode that actually stops and asks what that cost him instead of just gesturing at it.
What gets me is that the Dalek is barely dangerous when this starts. It’s bolted down, half-dead, unable to do more than swivel its eyestalk and beg in a small metallic voice for orders it isn’t going to get. The Doctor knows this and does it anyway, and Rose is the one standing there watching him become something she doesn’t recognise. That’s the first time all series I’ve felt like the show was asking me to be uncomfortable with its own hero rather than just worried for him. Nine hundred years old and the thing that finally cracks him open isn’t a monster at full strength. It’s one on its knees.
Van Statten’s Zoo
Van Statten is introduced as an eccentric with more money than sense, and the episode slowly turns that into something much nastier. He owns the Dalek the way a bad zoo owns a tiger, as a status object he doesn’t understand and won’t ask anyone smarter to explain. He’s collected wreckage from every crash landing his money can track down and buried the truth every time so he can keep the good stuff for himself, and the show doesn’t play that as harmless eccentricity, it plays it as theft on a planetary scale. Then it goes one further. When one of his own researchers works out too much about what’s really going on down there, van Statten has the man’s memory wiped and dumped on a street with no idea who he is. That’s not a throwaway detail. That’s the same instinct that keeps a wounded alien in chains for years, aimed at a human being instead.
It’s Adam Mitchell, one of van Statten’s own researchers, who ends up doing the closest thing to a decent job anyone in the bunker manages, and the episode plants him as someone the Doctor and Rose can’t quite shake off by the end of the hour. I liked that the show didn’t need a villain twirling a moustache to make its point about power. Van Statten never fires a weapon. He just decides who gets remembered and who doesn’t, and that’s plenty. By the time his own staff turn on him near the end and hand him the same treatment he’s been dishing out all episode, it doesn’t feel like justice so much as the bunker finally running on its own rules instead of his.
What Rose Does Without Meaning To
While the Doctor is off being cruel to a caged prisoner, Rose does the opposite thing. She’s the same shop girl who ran off with a stranger in a police box five weeks ago, and she’s still curious rather than afraid, so she talks to it, and eventually she touches it, and that’s the moment the episode turns. The Dalek pulls something from her, DNA and static and whatever else counts as fuel to it, and uses it to force its own cell open. From there it’s not a caged animal anymore. It’s the thing everyone in the bunker should have been afraid of from the start, working out doors it shouldn’t be able to open and finding new ways to kill soldiers who thought a locked room made them safe.
But the DNA does something else too, something nobody in the bunker sees coming and the Dalek doesn’t either. It starts to feel things it has no protocol for. It hesitates. It asks itself a question a Dalek has never had to ask before, which is what it actually wants, rather than what it’s built to do. Other Doctor Who fans have pointed at that exact hinge as the reason this episode stands out, a monster the show has always kept simple suddenly getting complicated in real time, on screen, without a word of it feeling like a cheat.
The Order Rose Couldn’t Give
The end of this one is where it earns everything the first forty minutes set up. The Dalek, half-changed and horrified by what it’s become, climbs to the surface and opens itself to actual sunlight for the first time, and just stands there feeling it on what’s left of its casing. It’s a strange thing to find moving, a war machine having what looks like the first good moment of its existence, but I did. Then the Doctor catches up with a weapon in his hand, ready to finish what he started in the cage, and it’s Rose who gets between them.
The Dalek asks her for an order. Not the Doctor, her. It wants to be told to die, because it can’t bear what it’s turned into and it won’t do it without permission, and Rose can’t say the word. She just can’t get it out. So the Dalek does it itself, and what’s left of it dies alone on a rooftop having chosen its own ending rather than had one handed to it. The Doctor doesn’t get to be the one who solves this. He gets to stand there and watch what nearly killing a defenceless prisoner in a cage actually cost him, and Eccleston plays the silence after it better than almost anything else he does in the role.
Rose ends the episode a bit shaken by the man she’s travelling with, and rightly so, and Adam talks his way onto the TARDIS in the last few minutes in a way that feels like it’s going to cause problems rather than solve any. I’ve got no idea yet whether that’s a good idea on the show’s part. What I do know is that five episodes of monsters and jokes just got followed by one that made me rethink what kind of man is flying that box, and that’s a much better trick than another rubber suit chasing people down a corridor. I went in expecting a runaround with a famous name attached and came out having watched the Doctor nearly become the thing he’s spent nine hundred years fighting.
3 comments